CFOtech UK - Technology news for CFOs & financial decision-makers
United Kingdom
UK firms struggle to prove impact of social schemes

UK firms struggle to prove impact of social schemes

Wed, 18th Nov 2026 (Today)
Karen Joy Bacudo
KAREN JOY BACUDO Finance Editor

Thrive has published research showing that companies struggle to measure the impact of their social initiatives. The study reviewed 900 ESG reports from 840 businesses across seven markets.

The analysis found that reporting is still centred on spending, participation and activity rather than outcomes. None of the ten most commonly disclosed social metrics directly measures change attributable to a programme.

Across the seven markets, social measurement maturity averaged between 1.5 and 1.9 on a scale of 0 to 4. The UK scored 1.8, behind the US and Europe at 1.9, but ahead of Australia at 1.7, Asia at 1.6 and India at 1.5.

The data points to a mismatch between the scale of corporate social activity and the evidence companies publish on its effects. Nearly three-quarters of businesses, or 74%, reported community investment and philanthropy activities, while 73% discussed employee wellbeing initiatives.

Reporting becomes thinner when it moves from describing programmes to measuring results. Seven in ten companies reported employee engagement initiatives, but only 32% published engagement scores. While 73% discussed employee wellbeing, only 3% disclosed absenteeism figures.

Common measures

The most frequently reported metrics were employee headcount, disclosed by 685 of the 840 companies reviewed; community investment and charitable donations, reported by 528; and employee training hours or investment, reported by 467. These figures show the volume of activity but offer limited evidence of whether a programme changed behaviour, improved retention or affected wellbeing.

Among the 200 UK companies examined separately for the reasons behind social investment, 67% cited attracting and retaining employees. That was well ahead of risk management at 28%, brand reputation at 22% and customer retention at 20%.

The findings suggest many businesses are linking social investment to workforce goals without publishing the data needed to test whether those goals are being met. The report also highlighted a lack of comparable measures across different types of programmes, with volunteering often assessed in hours, donations in pounds and training in headcount.

That creates a problem for executives trying to compare initiatives or defend budgets. If one programme is measured in time, another in cash and a third in participant numbers, boards and investors have less basis for judging which interventions are producing stronger results.

"Our research shows that the problem isn't a lack of social initiatives; companies are doing great work. Rather, it's a lack of evidence about the difference they're making. That should reassure business leaders, because it doesn't mean they need to start from scratch or launch more programmes to make progress. The priority now is to measure existing activity more consistently, so organisations can understand what's working and where they can have the greatest impact," Benjamin Fellowes, Co-Founder and Chief Product & Strategy Officer at Thrive, said.

Commercial pressure

The research comes as companies face closer scrutiny over ESG disclosures and the business case for social spending. In the UK sample, the prominence of employee attraction and retention as a stated motivation suggests social programmes are increasingly tied to commercial objectives rather than treated only as philanthropic activity.

Without outcome data, companies may find it harder to justify continued spending when budgets tighten. The study argues that activity-based reporting does not provide a clear enough picture of effectiveness for internal decision-making.

Thrive also pointed to examples from the construction sector where more structured measurement has been linked to commercial results. VolkerLaser, part of VolkerWessels UK, reported 20% higher bid scores after strengthening its approach to social impact and recorded £48.1 million in social impact in 2023 against a target of £28.5 million.

Laing O'Rourke, meanwhile, demonstrated additional social impact equivalent to 11% of client spend on a project. These examples show how some companies are trying to express social outcomes in terms that are easier for clients and decision-makers to assess.

The wider picture from the study, however, is that such measurement remains uncommon. For most companies in the sample, published ESG reporting still says more about what was funded or delivered than about what changed as a result.