CFOtech UK - Technology news for CFOs & financial decision-makers
United Kingdom
UK consumers reject AI alone for bank charge disputes

UK consumers reject AI alone for bank charge disputes

Wed, 18th Nov 2026 (Today)
Karen Joy Bacudo
KAREN JOY BACUDO Finance Editor

Five9 has published research suggesting most UK consumers do not want AI to handle charge disputes alone in financial services. The findings point to a strong preference for human involvement in sensitive customer service cases.

Among 413 UK consumers who had contacted financial services customer service in the previous six months, 51% said charge disputes should be handled entirely by a person. A further 37% said they would accept AI involvement if a human provided direct oversight or approval. Only 13% said AI should deal with such disputes independently.

The data also showed a broad expectation that people should remain involved in other consequential interactions. Some 91% said high-stakes escalations should involve a human, including 63% who want them handled entirely by a person. Another 86% said refunds or financial adjustments should include human involvement, while 85% said the same of sensitive identity verification.

The research adds to the wider debate over how far banks and other financial institutions should automate customer service as AI adoption spreads across the sector. A joint survey by the Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority found that 86% of responding financial services firms were already using AI.

While Five9's analysis found resistance to autonomous decision-making in more serious cases, it also suggested consumers are not rejecting the technology outright. Among people who had recently contacted financial services providers, 52% said AI is useful for customer service, compared with 42% of those who had not.

Consumers appeared more willing to accept AI for routine tasks. More than three-quarters (77%) said AI can play a role in order or account status enquiries, including 35% who said it could handle those requests independently.

Where consumers draw the line

The figures suggest a divide between using AI for straightforward administrative interactions and using it in cases with financial consequences for customers. That distinction is likely to matter for lenders, insurers and other providers trying to reduce service costs while avoiding disputes over accountability.

The results came from Five9's 2026 Consumer CX Report. The company worked with Hanover Research on an online survey of 3,000 consumers across the UK, the US and Germany, including 1,000 UK respondents.

This financial services analysis focused on the 413 UK respondents who had contacted customer service in the sector during the previous six months. Respondents could select more than one industry, and the findings reflect views on customer service generally rather than on financial services interactions alone.

That methodological point matters when interpreting the results. The figures do not show how consumers judged a single bank or insurer, but they do provide a snapshot of where respondents appear willing to accept automation and where they still want a named person involved.

Human oversight

For financial institutions, the findings underscore the operational and governance challenge of introducing AI into service functions without removing human judgement from contentious or higher-risk processes. Areas such as disputed charges, refunds and identity checks can trigger complaints, regulatory scrutiny and reputational damage if customers believe decisions were made unfairly or without recourse.

Andy Dignan, President of Five9, said: "The question for banks isn't whether AI belongs in customer service, but where it should be allowed to act alone. Customers may be comfortable with AI answering a straightforward account enquiry, but a disputed charge or sensitive financial issue demands a different level of care.

"Financial institutions should be measuring success by more than the number of interactions they can automate. The real opportunity is to use AI to make routine service faster and more effective, while ensuring human judgement and accountability remain central when the stakes are higher."